News·27 Oct 2026

Florida seeks $10,000 a willful violation from First Street, the firm whose flood scores are offered through Zillow, Realtor.com and Redfin

The complaint, e-filed in Polk County on 23 October, says buyers are dealing with "fake flood risk". Nebraska filed a similar suit about two months earlier, HousingWire reports; Texas is party to neither.

By Daily Aletheia · Office of the Attorney General of Florida v. First Street Technology, Inc. - Complaint, Polk County circuit court, e-filed 23 Oct 2026 (PDF) ↗ · 2 min read

FEMA - Flooded neighborhood in Central Florida, photo by Barry Bahler (FEMA 37558), Wikimedia Commons, public domain (US federal government image)

Florida's Attorney General has sued First Street Technology, Inc., the firm whose Risk Factor scores rate a property's flood, fire, wind, air quality and heat risk from 1 to 10. The complaint, e-filed on 23 October 2026 in the circuit court in Polk County, says First Street breaks the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act.

It opens: "Deciding to buy a home these days is hard enough without dealing with fake flood risk." The state says First Street offers its Risk Factor scores "through publicly accessible real estate platforms, such as Redfin, Zillow and Realtor.com" and uses that reach to sell paid property reports, while the data behind the free scores sits behind a paywall.

The state asks for civil penalties of $10,000 for each willful violation and $15,000 for each violation that victimized a senior citizen or a person with a disability, disgorgement of what it calls ill-gotten gains, and its attorneys' fees. It also asks the court to stop First Street calling its scores "accurate" without disclosing the uncertainty in them, calling them "transparent" while data sits behind a paywall, and calling them "peer reviewed" in a way that suggests each property's own score was.

Nebraska's attorney general, Mike Hilgers, filed a similar suit about two months earlier, HousingWire reports. His complaint, in the district court of Dakota County, says First Street passes off "inflated and inherently speculative predictions" about every Nebraska property's flood risk as concrete, objective facts.

As of Tuesday morning, Zillow, Redfin and Realtor.com were all still showing First Street data or links to it with listings, HousingWire reports, and Zillow removed some of the data in December 2025 after the California Regional MLS questioned its accuracy. First Street did not immediately answer HousingWire's request for comment.

Texas is not a party to either suit. Both complaints are the states' allegations; no court has ruled on them.

Sources and Further Reading

  1. 01Office of the Attorney General of Florida v. First Street Technology, Inc. - Complaint, Polk County circuit court, e-filed 23 Oct 2026 (PDF) ↗Primary
  2. 02State of Nebraska ex rel. Hilgers v. First Street Technology, Inc. - Complaint, Dakota County district court (PDF) ↗Primary
  3. 03HousingWire - Climate risk scores could be hurting home sales, two states allege in lawsuits (27 Oct 2026) ↗Attributed